Teacher Of the Deaf/Staff Clear Mask/Shield Pro Con List, CrowdSource

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O	P	Q	R	S
1	To Update/Add to List please "Add comment" or email: leslie.manjarrez@gmail.com														Key			Disclaimer: This free sheet was made as a crowdsourced document to put together resources in one place and is not endorsing, supporting or disproving any and all products, articles or resources shown here. This is also not a complete resource and is only as accurate as the feedback given through online forums, research and articles presented on the internet
2
3	General Information Sites DHH Specific:							General Information Sites Safety(Federal, etc):							Mask
4	How Do Medical Masks Degrade Speech Reception?							Face Shield Safety Study							Shield
5	California Hands and Voices "Rethinking Deaf and Hard of Hearing Accessibility in Post-COVID-19 Classrooms" Recommendations							WHO Advice and Guidelines on Use of Masks for COVID-19							Deaf Owned Masks(NON CLEAR WINDOW)
6	American Cochlear Implant Alliance Considerations Face Shields							CDC Mask Guidelines							COMMENT SECTION
7	"Factors that affect face shields and masks with clear windows, perspectives from people who are Deaf/Hard of Hearing"See Hear Communication Matters Survey, Developed by Tina Childress Carrie Spangler and Mary Beth Napoli							New England Journal of Medicine Study Shields and Masks Study and Directions of Use							Can masks/shields be Adapted for Use of Professionals who Use Hearing Aids, CIs, Glasses?
8	The Impact of Personal Protection Equipment on Remote Microphones Oticon PD(REQUIRES Download of "ADOBE CONNECT" has CAPTIONS Available)							Considerations for Wearing Cloth Face Coverings(CDC Information Updated 6/28/2020)							State Guidelines
9	Childress et al Survey RESPONSES							CDC "Checklist: Planning for In-Person Class" Parent Checklist							Examples:
10	Connect, Hear List of Vendors for Masks(Many of the same ones here and has some other companies too)							CDC Guidelines on Re-opening Schools-Updated July 23, 2020						Works	Works 50%	Does Not Work	No Current Data
11	Phonak Sanitizing FM Systems							CDC "Supporting Deaf Children during COVID-19"						Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
12	Phonak, "The Masking Dilemma Revisited" Directives when Using Masks with DHH							CDC "Opening Schools During COVID, Considerations" Updated Aug 21, 2020
13	Strategies to Keep Clear Windows from Fogging Up, Knowledge Base Link							CDC "Preparing K-12 Schools, Administrators"
14	American Cochlear Implant Alliance, Consideration of Face Shields as a Return to School Option, Opinion Writing
15	Kentucky Hands and Voices, Considerations for In Person Instruction PDF Recommendations
16	Listen with Lindsey-"Improve Communication While Wearing a Mask"
17	National Deaf Center(NDC) "Communicating with a Face Mask: What Colleges Need to Know for Deaf Students(and Everyone)"
18	Tina Childress: How Masks affect Speech Perception, Graphic dB
19	ASHA: "Media Spotlight: Masks and Communication"
20	Moog Center For Deaf Education, Speech Perception, Masks Study Aug 2020
21							Special Thanks to Gail F for support in research for this column	Anti Fog Product Example, Amazon	The Hearing Spot-"Care and Use of the Clear Panel Mask"			ASL, LSL and Cued Speech will be based on Feedback about USE of Product and Access in Language(Feedback Welcome via facebook or email or here by "Insert, +comment")
22		COMMENT SECTION: Pick a box in light pink, go to "insert" go to "Add Comment" then type comment	Name	Visual	Source(Etsy, Facebook Shop, Factory, Make[yourself], Small Buisness)	Website	Pricing	Fogs?	Maintainence	Pros	Cons	ASL	LSL	Cued Speech		State by State Guidelines			Can Masks/Shields be Adapted for Use of Professionals who Use Hearing Aids, CIs, Glasses?
23	1		Emily Mask(Youtuber)		Make[yourself]	Youtube Link (Has Captions)	Directions to hand make	No(Using Hacks from her Tutorial, does fog up without the tips/hacks from tutorial)	Hand Wash, Air Dry	DEAF CREATED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive		California Department of Health Guidance for Face Coverings			Advanced Bionics, Tips for putting on masks with Cochlear Implants Tip Sheet with Visuals(Sample to the Right)
24	2		Cricut Window Mask		Make[yourself]	Make Your Own, Pattern Link	Directions to hand make	Yes		Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive		New Jersey Department of Education Guidelines "Recovery and Restart"			Tips from AB appear to be able to be used in general for long term Mask wear as well as for HA users and for Glasses users. Include different types of masks as well as different adaptations
25	3		Fully Enclosed Face Shield Hood		Make[yourself]	Link to Blog with Directions	Directions to hand make	Minimal Fogging	Washable for Repeated Use	Reusable	NOT OSHA certified	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive		Illinois State Board of Education Guidelines TDLR: Face Shields have not been deemed effective, use masks unless nothing else is available to you
26	4		Rafi Nova		Factory	Rafi Nova Website, "Smile Collection"	The Smile Masks: tie behind $30.00 The Smile Masks: ear loops $30.00 Kids Smile Mask $12.00 Teacher Bundles: $15.00 (Mon-Tues - 1 smile mask 1 everyday masks) Teacher Bundles: ? Cost (Mon-Fri *sold out - 2 smile mask 3 everyday masks) Classroom Bundles: Smile bundle - $120.00 = 2 adults and 15 kids smile masks Preschool bundle - $99.00 = 2 adults and 15 toddler performance masks / not clear Elementary bundle - $99.00 = 2 adults and 15 kids everyday elevated masks / not clear High school bundle - $99.00 = 15 adulte everyday elevated masks / not clear Shipping: USPS - First Class Mail $4.20 Fed Ex Priority $9.50	Yes	Link to Limited Edition "Mille Smile Mask"	Limited Edition DEAF COLLABORATION Avaliable(Millicent Simmonds), Bulk Orders Avaliable, CHILD SIZE AVALIABLE	Fogs easily, needs anti-fog treatment It was loose, needed extenders for it to fit properly, then it was fine.	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive					Link to additional ETSY Shops for Buttons, Extendors and "Ear Savers" for CI, HA and Glasses adaptations
27	5		ClearMask		Factory	ClearMask Website	Box (24 masks) - $67.00 / sale Case (432 masks) - $1,199.00 / sale Discounted Case (432 masks per case) w/ minimum purchase of 8 cases - $1,145.00 / sale	Yes		DEAF OWNED, Medical Grade, Bulk Ordering Avaliable	Meant for Single Use, From a user: Loss of dB evident when put on, Bulk Orders Only, Large gaps in the sides, functions more of a mouth shield than a mask	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Many people have stated this mask does not work as intended and becomes hot, the sponge becomes wet, the sides don't offer much protection and the fit is not gret
28	6		Bendshape Mask		Factory	Bendshape Mask	3 Pack-$27 8 Pack-$70 Plus shipping, comes with white cord, color cords(in various colors) 1.50 each	No	X2 Washing, Instructions on Site	Reusable X2		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Users have said this is a good mask for usability and also is able to fit many different faces due to the "bendability" and has one of the largest clear windows				Adapter for Masks, Visual to the Right of Link
29	7		KN95 with Clear Insert		Factory	School Health KN95 with Clear Insert	Adult Size 1 for $21.99, Youth Size in 5 Pack for $21.99	No		Resusable with proper storage between usage		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
30	8		Moon Dang Online Shop		Facebook	Facebook Link to Moon Dang Shop	Facebook - check for pricing	Yes		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
31	9		DomRich Studio		Etsy	Link to Etsy Shop DomRich Studio	Pricing: $7.00 and Up	Yes		CHILD SIZES AVALIABLE, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
32	10		The Communicator(tm) Surgical Mask		Factory	SafenClear Website	Back order Dispenser boxes: 40 masks Item FM 86000 - $60.00 Cases: 10 Dispenser boxes x 40 masks = 400 masks Item FM 86000 - $540.00	Yes		Medical Grade	Meant for Single Use	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
33		COMMENT SECTION: Pick a box in light pink, go to "insert" go to "Add Comment" then type comment	Name	Visual	Source(Etsy, Facebook Shop, Factory, Make[yourself], Small Buisness)	Website	Pricing	Fogs?	Maintainence	Pros	Cons	ASL	LSL	Cued Speech
34	11		Etsy Clear Window Seller 1		Etsy	SaraSewShop	Pricing: $16.00 Shipping: $3.31 (1) Shipping: $4.08 (2) Shipping: $5.27 (3)	Yes		Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive					Basically No From a user: It also brushes up against my glasses and the glare is doubled (glasses and shield) which gave me a headache!
35	12		Friendly Face Mask		Small Business	Friendly Face Mask(UK)	Adult - $15.00 Child - $12.50 Flat Shipping - $2.50	Yes		Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
36	13		Clear Mouth Face Mask		Factory	AVC Custom Cases	Pricing: $2.50/face mask w/ quantity orders of <100 $3.00/face mask w/ quantity orders of >99 minimum order of 10 face masks Shipping rates: $8.40 for 100 or less $15.00 for 100-200 orders over 200 are calculated at checkout	Yes		Reusable,Bulk Ordering Avaliable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
37	14		Mask of Hope		Facebook	Facebook Page	Facebook - check for pricing	Yes		DEAF OWNED, Reusable, Quick Reply on Facebook Chat		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
38	15		Show My Smile		Small Business	Show My Smile Website	Pricing: $14.99 (or - bundles) 3 Smile masks $39.99 5 Smile masks $64.99 10 Smile masks $119.99 Anti Fog 1oz spray 9.99	Yes		Reusable, Orders Come with Free sanitizing anitfog product, CHILD SIZE AVALIABLE		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
39	16		Abrams Nation		Small Business	Abram's Nation Website	Pricing: $18.00 Each	Yes	Machine washable & dryable. Any water temp. Any dryer temp.	Reusable, Anti-microbial and wicking fabric, Wired		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
40	17		Klodia's Face Masks		Facebook	Facebook Link to Klodia's Face Mask	Pricing: $15.00 Shipping: $5.00	Yes		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
41	18		Clear Masks That Don’t Fog Up by Karina Ruiz		Factory/Small Business	Contact Karinaruiz015@yahoo.com or 708-369-0320	$10 each. Company has black light gray colors available. Orders of 100 or more can customize in any color of your choice. Company can create children sizes, need the age range. Shipping cost would be waived for more than 200 clear masks.	No		Bulk Orders Avaliable, Reusable, Factory made not homemade	User reported: Has Huge gaps on the side for them	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
42	19		LEAF N99 Clear Mask		Factory(but currently not avaliable), Shipping in August 2020(Read Rumors that it has been delayed until Sept 2020)	Link to Indiegogo Campaign	See PDF in this Link- No 17 word document - (varied pricing from - $49.99 / single to $379.00 for pack deals	Unknown		Medical Grade(N99)	Currently Unavliable	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
43	20		ADCO Communicator(Window) Mask		Factory	ADCO Hearing Product Website	Pricing: $15.99 Shipping: small items (3 or less) $5.00 Up to 100 = $9.50 " " 300 = $13.75 " " 500 = $18.00 501+ = 3.40% of subtotal 1500+ = 3.15% of subtotal *upgrade charge for faster shipping range from +5.00 to +30.00 / depending on the address / 2 days or overnight	Yes but has "Care Kit" avaliable for seperate purchase here for anti-fog	From Website: Machine wash on cold and air-dry. Check out our ADCO Mask Care Kit for everything you need to properly wash and defog!, CHILD SIZE AVALIABLE	Resuable	From a user: Not recommended, so big that it falls off my face(has a failry averge sized face) even when you tighten the elastic its way too big and doesn't conform to face, leaves gaps on all sides	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
44		COMMENT SECTION: Pick a box in light pink, go to "insert" go to "Add Comment" then type comment	Name	Visual	Source(Etsy, Facebook Shop, Factory, Make[yourself], Small Buisness)	Website	Pricing	Fogs?	Maintainence	Pros	Cons	ASL	LSL	Cued Speech
45	21		Face Bandanas with Detachable Eyes Shield (PVC)		Factory	Amazon	Pricing: Adults (list price $39.98) actual price $15.99 Kids (list price $44.98) actual price $17.99	Yes		Resuable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
46	22		ItsPhun		Small Business	ItsPhun Website To Order	Contact Website Directly	Unkown	Three Avaliable: Clear Mask, Transparent Mask, Shield	Resuable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
47	23		Kaplan		Factory	Kaplan Company Website	Pricing: $39.95 for a Set of Five	Yes	Bendable nose wire for the ultimate fit. Masks are washable, but need to air dry.	Resuable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
48	24		Aid the Silent		Small Business	Website Aid the Silent	$15.00	No, Clear Mouth Window – 100% acetate anti-fog treated	Washable	Resuable, Adjustable Ear Loops for Larger Ears	From a User: The plastic split in the middle, too thin, lost my money because they won't refund if plastic breaks	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
49	25		Share a Smile		Facebook	Facebook Market Place	Pricing: $15.00 Shipping: $3.00	Yes	From the Maker: Removable window so you can wash in the washing machine (comes with 2!)	Reusable, Machine Washable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
50	26		Adorable Crafts by Lisa		Etsy	Adorable Crafts by Lisa	Varies by type, has shield and non clear mask avaliable	Yes	Washable	Resuable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
51	27		Window Masks for Deaf HH by David Mickelsen		Small Business/Etsy	Link to Etsy Shop, can also email at daviddsns@aol.com or message on FB	$20.00	Yes, however can treat with a few drops of anti-fog Spray and will not fog for a period of time	Hand Wash, Hang Dry	Resuable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
52	28		GForm Face Shield		Small Business	Turk Giovanucci Mobile: 617-688-5141 Email: TurkGava@mac.com	See PDF in this Link	No		Reusable, Child and Adult Size avaliable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
53	29		Face Shield		Factory	Amazon	AMAZON - price range $7.50-$154.25 depending on quantities ordered	Yes		Resuable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
54	30		Face Shield(Generic)		Factory	Oaktree Products	Item KCMFS-2925 at $9.50 each: https://www.oaktreeproducts.com/face-shield-clear-adjustable-elastic-strap-reusable-each-kcmfs-2925 Item DMSHIELD at $6.00 each (although the actual shield part is a little flimsier, hence the lower price) https://www.oaktreeproducts.com/face-shield-clear-adjustable-reusable-each-dmshield Item B56987 at $10.75 each https://www.oaktreeproducts.com/face-shield-clear-adjustable-reusable-each-b56987 We also have Item INFS220 at $7 each but we do not have stock and not sure when the next shipment is coming in: https://www.oaktreeproducts.com/unavailable-face-shield-clear-elastic-band-reusable-each-infs220	Yes		Reusable,Bulk Ordering Avaliable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
55	31		Humanity Shield		Factory/Small Business	Humanity Shield Website	Pricing: Adult or Child - $59.60 for 1-9 orders Adult or Child - $49.60 for 10-49 Adult or Child - $39.60 for 50-999 **orders over 1000 - inquiry for additional pricing and shipping	Yes	Hand sanitizer will clean and anti-fog it can also use hand sanitizer to clean fabric.	DEAF OWNED, Reusable	Gets HOT pretty quickly, On the Expensive Side	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
56	32		InstaShield		Factory	InstaShield Website	Pricing: $2.99 per shield or - Packs of 5 = $14.95 Packs of 10 = $29.90 Packs of 100 = $299.00 Shipping calculated at checkout	Yes(without cleaning) No(by using hand sanitizer)	Requires hat or visor, clean with hand sanitizer then doesn't fog	Reusable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards, From a user: The shield doesn’t stay on the brim of my hat properly unless it’s smashed up against my nose	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
57	33		Shield Pals		Factory	Shield Pals Website	Pricing: $6.00 Varied collections - price range from: $5.00-$45.00 Shipping: 1-3 = $8.00 Shipping: 4-7 = $15.00 Shipping: 8-15 = $22.00 etc.	Yes		Friendly to Young Children	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
58		COMMENT SECTION: Pick a box in light pink, go to "insert" go to "Add Comment" then type comment	Name	Visual	Source(Etsy, Facebook Shop, Factory, Make[yourself], Small Buisness)	Website	Pricing	Fogs?	Maintainence	Pros	Cons	ASL	LSL	Cued Speech
59	34		Z Shield		Factory	ZVerse Website	Pricing: $22.99 (1) Pricing: $109.99 (5) Pricing: $212.99 (10) *Shipping extra	No		Reusable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards, Gets in the way of signing near the face. When using with preschoolers, playing on the floor, the students look down into the shield, making it ineffective. The angle of the tilt can be far from the face or so close it's touching your nose	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
60	35		Flip Up Top Shield		Etsy	Link to Etsy Shop	Pricing: $17.00	No	FREE EXTRA shield+ Rubber head protect	Resuable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
61	36		Badger Shield +		Factory(Not Currently Avaliable, Site States will be ready to Ship in Three Weeks as of 8/6/2020)	Link to 5 Pack Order Website	$125 for 5 $200 for 10 $450 for 25 $1,630 for 100 Free Ground Shipping in Lower 48, Ships within 1-2 days from order, Exppedited Shipping Available	No	Badger Shield+ was developed with UW Hospital, at the request of speech therapists and interpretive services to include an SMS surgical fabric enclosure under the chin so their entire face would be visible to their clients. The top of the cloth is cinched with an elastic band and cord lock, allowing adjustment of the shield opening by the ears for comfort.	Child Size and Bulk Ordering Avaliable	One Time Use, Meets almost all, but not all safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
62	37		Transparent Anti-Fog Spray Saliva Chef Spit Mouth Shield		Factory	Transparent Face Shield, Amazon	AMAZON - price range $4.74-$34.99 from the search various styles and brands several pages to scan	No		Reusable	Doesn't Meet all Safety Standards	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
63	38		HandmadewithASL		Small Business, NOT CLEAR MASK	Instagram @handmadewithasl	Instagram - check for pricing	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
64	39		FunMasks Shop		Small Business, NOT CLEAR MASK	FunMasks Website	Pricing: (from) $12.95 - $14.99	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
65	40		By Mara		Small Business, NOT CLEAR MASK	By Mara Website	Pricing: $15.00 - shipping: ?	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
66	41		SewCrazyVermont		Etsy, NOT CLEAR MASK	Link to Etsy Shop SewCrazy Vermont	Pricing: $16.00 - Free shipping	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
67	42		Inka's Screen Printing		Facebook, NOT CLEAR MASK	Facebook Link to Inka's Screen Printing	Facebook - check for pricing	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive
68	43		Mollie's Enchanted Thread		Facebook, NOT CLEAR MASK	Facebook Link to Millie's Enchanted Thread	Facebook - check for pricing	No		DEAF OWNED, Reusable		Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive	Expressive Receptive